More lifelike trading

45 votes

Currently, the player who accepts the trade offer first, gets the trade. The trade proposer should be able to agree to the trade being accepted and/or choose who to trade with.

Done enhance feature trade Suggested by: Stroom (07 Aug, '19) • Upvoted: 23 Aug, '20 • Comments: 8

Comments: 8

07 Aug, '19
Esqarrouth Admin
You've mentioned this suggestion like 4+ times. While I do agree it should be like this, the trade system isn't easy to change it to this method, because of the current design. However, if more people want this, or all other highly asked features are added, we'll add this.

Btw, this is what I'm hoping from featureupvote, the ability to vote on suggestions.
08 Aug, '19
Stroom
Yeah, I know. I posted it here so people could vote on it. I know it is hard to implement but I'd say that since trading is very important aspect of the game, it has to be done eventually.
08 Aug, '19
Dyl
I agree with stroom here. This is a huge part of trading. A lot of the time I throw out a trade to “probe” at other people and see what they want and why they want the trade. I can’t use probing trades on this place because it’ll simply get accepted.

This feature would be amazing.
08 Aug, '19
tuga
i think this could be nice if you remove the current "trade with user selection" and add a check mark for "choose who to trade with". this would allow probing and keep the design simple.
10 Aug, '19
corpsss
> i think this could be nice if you remove the current "trade with user selection" and add a check mark for "choose who to trade with". this would allow probing and keep the design simple.

no, that's not enough and is already available. If two players are willing to accept your trade, then you should have the choice of who to trade with.
20 Oct, '19
b
Disagree.

Second player should be tracking game better, and be faster. However, I think second player should be able to +1/improve offer upon offer accept (e.g. +5-10 second window). Will add this as separate feature request.
23 Oct, '19
PotatoRiot
I would suggest that this function would be implemented only on the slow games. In the fast games, it's nice to be able to trade fast and don't have to wait for each of the players to accept/decline in order to make a trade in seconds.
29 Oct, '19
Esqarrouth Admin
Released in Version 56